The underwear drawer is a good place to try a color you’d never buy in a sweater. You get to see it in the morning, then put on the same clothes you were going to wear anyway. The latest drop from Obviously Apparel offers four ways to make that small change. Burgundy is a deep wine shade, Dawn is a soft lavender, Capri is the more saturated blue and Turquoise is the lighter one. All four are listed in the EliteMan trunk, a short cut with a covered waistband that leaves most of the visual attention on the fabric itself.

A trunk makes sense as the starting point if you prefer a little fabric at the top of the thigh. It’s a shorter shape than a six-inch boxer brief, which matters when you wear a close-fitting pair of jeans and want less fabric down the leg. The EliteMan version uses a stretchy MicroModal blend and the brand’s contoured AnatoMax pouch, designed to make room at the front. The waistband is covered in fabric, so the color reads across the garment without the visual interruption of large lettering. You can pick a shade with the same eye you’d bring to a plain T-shirt.

Burgundy is an easy way into color for anyone whose drawer looks like a stack of black jeans. It’s dark enough to sit comfortably alongside charcoal, navy or washed black, while the red is clear when you see it on its own. It also makes a good choice if you want something that feels at home in colder weather. You can wear it with whatever you already own. If you’ve always bought black because it’s familiar, try Burgundy in a cut you know and see whether it gets the same amount of use once it’s in the drawer.

Dawn does something quieter. Its lavender tone has a softness that makes it feel at home near heather gray and faded blue. In the EliteMan trunk, the covered waistband gives the shade a clean line at the waist. If you’re used to white underwear and want a pale color, Dawn brings a little more contrast without going vivid. It’s also the easiest shade to distinguish from the two blues in morning light. People often think of color in terms of matching, but it can be useful to think about how readily you’ll recognize each pair once the laundry is folded.

Capri and Turquoise are more interesting together than the names might suggest. Capri appears brighter and more saturated in the product photographs. Turquoise is the pale, cooler blue of the two. The distinction matters if you’re adding just one shade. If you want the pair that will stand out immediately next to the clothes you already own, Capri is the better place to begin. If you want the gentler shade, look at Turquoise.

There’s a practical side to shopping for colorful mens underwear. Decide what you want to keep about the pairs that work for you already. You may like the height of the waistband on your favorite trunk, or you may always wear longer boxer briefs because you prefer more fabric between your thighs on a long walk. The EliteMan listings also show the four colors in six-inch and nine-inch boxer briefs. You can choose the shade you like without giving up the coverage that makes a certain pair work with your usual clothes. That’s especially helpful if you’re ordering the first pair online.

The best underwear for men is often the pair they reach for again after the first wash, once the novelty has worn off. Try your new color in a familiar outfit and check how the waistband feels while you sit. See where the leg ends when you move and whether it still feels comfortable on the way home. Wash the pair according to its label and see if you reach for it again. Those small observations are helpful if you’re deciding whether you want one bright pair for a change of pace or several pairs in the same cut.

If you want to build a drawer with more variation, go one pair at a time. Burgundy and Dawn give you a dark and a light option with a clear distinction between them. Capri and Turquoise let you build around blue without repeating the same shade. You can also choose a single color to use across two cuts, such as a trunk for slim trousers and a longer boxer brief for a day of walking. Once you’ve tried the first one, you’ll know whether the color deserves more space and whether the cut belongs in rotation.

There’s no special occasion required to wear any of the four. Pick the cut you know you’ll use on an ordinary day and let the color be the small surprise. For one person, that may be the Burgundy pair next to the black ones. For another, it may be the first time a soft lavender has made its way into the wardrobe. Either choice works if it makes getting dressed a little more enjoyable on a morning when the rest of your outfit is already decided.

Written in partnership with Tom White